Endoscopic endonasal cerebrospinal fluid rhinorrhea repair: a cohort study in Iraq

Abstract

Background

Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) rhinorrhea is a condition where the protective fluid that surrounds the brain finds its way into the nose and sinuses, often appearing as a very watery runny nose. The main surgical approaches for the surgical repair of CSF leaks are intracranial and extracranial. Over the last decade, endoscopic surgery has established itself as the most widely used technique for the repair of CSF fistula. The current study aimed to describe the use of nasal endoscopic technique in the management of cerebrospinal fluid rhinorrhea repair.

Results

Results of our study showed that in addition to CSF leak, 40% of the patients had headache and 17.5% had repeated meningitis. Half of the etiologies for the CSF leak were spontaneous, 35% were congenital, and 15% were traumatic. The more frequent site of leak was left cribriform plate (37.5%). In the majority of patients, 37/40 (92.5%), the type of graft was tensor fascia lata and fat, while in the remaining 3 patients, type of graft was tensor fascia lata and bone, bone and fat, and tensor fascia lata. The repair succeeded in 35 patients giving a success rate of 87.5%.

Conclusion

It can be concluded that wide range of age groups from 2–62 years presented as CSF rhinorrhea with female predominance, and there was high success rate of endoscopic CSF rhinorrhea repair with low morbidity.

Background

Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) rhinorrhea is a condition where the protective fluid that surrounds the brain finds its way into the nose and sinuses, often appearing as a very watery runny nose. Most cases of CSF rhinorrhea occur after major accidents where the bones of the face and skull experience significant trauma [1]. The main surgical approaches for the surgical repair of CSF leaks are intracranial and extracranial [2].

There has been a shift over the last 30 years while choosing the best approach given the advancements made in endoscopic techniques. The endoscopic-guided approach for repair of CSF rhinorrhea offers the benefit of both panoramic and detailed image of the site of surgery, in fact owing to the specific direction of view of endoscopic lens system. It is possible to inspect the circumference of the operating field at 360° by rotating the telescope around its longitudinal axis which enable direct endonasal access to the anatomical structures at rhinobase without the need for cutaneous incision or cutting through bony segments and without dislodgement of bone structure [2].

Outcomes with endoscopic repair of CSF leaks are generally over 90% according to multiple studies [3,4,5]. The highest failure rates occur in individuals with spontaneous leaks and intracranial hypertension. However, management of this subset of patients is successful in over (90%) at 3 years when intracranial hypertension is appropriately managed [6]. Unfortunately, CSF pressure cannot be checked periodically due to the invasive nature of lumbar punctures. Medical treatment with acetazolamide or frequent monitoring by neurosurgeons of implanted VP shunts is the best option at this time. Decreasing the underlying intracranial hypertension is essential for increasing success rates in patients with spontaneous CSF leaks [7].

Since Dandy [8] described the first case of intracranial repair of CSF rhinorrhea by way of a bi-frontal craniotomy, this approach remained the mainstream of surgical treatment until Dohlman [9] reported the first case treated with an extracranial non endoscopic approach by way of a naso-frontal incision. Since then, a variety of endonasal approaches has evolved. In 1952, Hirsch [10] performed the first transnasal approach to close a sphenoid sinus leak. Vrabec and Hallberg [11] undertook an intranasal approach to manage cribriform plate leaks in 1964. Wigand [12], in 1981, was the first to describe the use of an endoscope in the treatment of CSF rhinorrhea incurred during FESS. Mattox and Kennedy [13] reported their seven successful repairs with free grafts and defined the indication of endoscopic technique for CSF repair. With the rapid development of endoscopic instrumentation, which has markedly improved the visualization of the entire roof of the sinonasal region and contributed to the surgical technique. An increasing number of surgeons have begun using the endoscope to repair CSF leaks and skull defects [14].

The objective of this study was to describe the use of nasal endoscopic technique in the management of cerebrospinal fluid rhinorrhea repair.

Methods

Study design and participants

This cohort study was conducted during the period from March 2014 to November 2018 on 40 patients (11 males and 29 females) who were referred to the otolaryngology department at (Ghazi AL- Hariri hospital for surgical specialties – Baghdad / Medical city), with a possible clinical diagnosis of CSF rhinorrhea. Twenty patients had spontaneous rhinorrhea, 14 patients had congenital meningiocele, and 6 patients had post-traumatic rhinorrhea. The duration of symptoms ranged from 2 to 22 months. All patients had failed to respond to conservative treatment in form of acetazolamide to decrease intracranial pressure.

Patients underwent a thorough past medical history including history of meningitis and surgical history like previous sinus surgeries, trauma, drug and social history, history of unilateral watery nasal discharge, history of headache, postnasal salty dripping, repeated dry coughing, clinical history, in addition to examination and analysis of the glucose concentration of the nasal discharge. Moreover, all the patients underwent computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

Full otorhinolaryngological examination was done. Endoscopic examination was done using local decongestant in the form of xylometazoline nasal drops 0.1% and topical anesthesia in the form of lidocaine spray, with the aid of 0, 30, 70° rigid scope.

All patients were sent for neurological assessments and optic disc examination for papilledema in cases of spontaneous CSF leak. Acetazolamide was taken in most of our patients especially those with traumatic CSF leak.

All surgeries were done under general (combined gas and intravenous drugs) anesthesia with oral endotracheal intubation.

When the patient recovered from the anesthesia, he/she was transferred to the ward and kept under the following: hourly chart for monitoring the vital signs, head elevation 15°, broad spectrum antibiotics (injectable ceftraixone in a dose of 50–100 mg per kg for 5 days), diuretics; at first day (injectable furosemide in a dose of 1–2 mg/kg/in three doses), then changed to oral acetazolamide in the second day. Moreover, a stool softener was given to decrease any possibility of increase intraabdominal pressure which may affect the procedure outcome. An oral antihistamine was given to suppress any sneezing that might increase intracranial pressure. Analgesic was given in the form of acetaminophen or tramadol (oral and injectable). Antiemetic and cough suppressant was given on need.

Patients stayed in the hospital until the nasal pack was removed. Kennedy Sinuspack which is used to prevent adhesion formation and post-operatory restenosis was usually removed at fifth to seventh day; once the packs were removed; medications were prescribed. Oral antibiotics were given for the next 10 days and oral acetazolamide was given for 1 month. Oral potassium supplement was given for 1 month (in conjunction with acetazolamide).

Patients were advised for a weekly visit in the first month and a monthly visit afterwards for endoscopic examination and assessment for at least 3 months.

Inclusion/exclusion criteria

Inclusion criteria to the study were traumatic CSF leak and non-traumatic CSF leak, while exclusion criteria were post-operative skull base tumor complicated by CSF rhinorrhea.

Ethical considerations

The study was approved by the (blinded for review). Moreover, confidentiality of all information collected in this study was guaranteed, as well as all data were protected through appropriate measures. Written informed consent was obtained from all participants.

Statistical analysis

Data of all patients were entered and managed using the statistical package for social sciences (SPSS) software (version 25). Descriptive statistics of the variables were expressed as mean, standard deviation, median, range, frequencies, and percentages.

Results

Age and gender distribution of the studied groups is presented in Table 1. Females represented (72.5%) of the studied group with a female to male ratio of almost (2.63:1). Additionally, 10 patients had their CSF leak since birth while the duration of CSF leak in the remaining 30 patients ranged between 2 and 22 months.

Table 1 Age and gender distribution of the studied groups

Table 2 summarizes the distribution of symptoms associated with CSF leak. Regarding the symptoms, in addition to CSF leak, 16(40%) of the patients had headache, 7(17.5%) had repeated meningitis, 4 (10%) had nasal obstruction, 2(5%) had repeated cough, and 3 (7.5%) patients had other symptoms including intraoperative leak, 3rd cranial nerve palsy, post-surgery leak; however, 8 (20%) patients had CSF leak only with no other associated symptoms.

Table 2 Distribution of symptoms associated with CSF leak

Table 3 summarizes the etiologies of CSF leak. Half of the patients had spontaneous CSF leak, 14(35%) patients had congenital, and 6 (15%) patients were traumatic; (5) of them surgical and the remaining 1 with head trauma.

Table 3 Etiologies of CSF leak

As for the site of CSF leak, it is presented in Table 4. The more frequent site of leak was left cribriform plate which accounted for 37.5%, followed by right cribriform plate (27.5%). Left ethmoid sinus roof was the site of leak in 10%, while each of right ethmoid sinus roof and sphenoid sinus accounted for 12.55%.

Table 4 Site of CSF leak

Table 5 summarizes the Distribution of the studied group according to the size of defect. Meningocele was reported in 18(45%), recurrence in 5 (12.5%) of cases, while skull base defect on CT was seen in 31(77.5%) of patients.

Table 5 Distribution of the studied group according to the size of defect

The distribution of the studied group according to the size of defect revealed that 3 (8%) patients had a defect of more than 1 cm and the remaining 37 (92.5%) patients were with a defect less than 1 cm as shown in Fig. 1.

Fig. 1

Distribution of the studied group according to the size of defect

In majority of patients, 37/40 (92.5%), the type of graft was Tensor Fascia Lata (TFL) and fat while in the remaining 3(7.5%) patients, the type of graft was TFL and bone, bone and fat, and tensor fascia lata as shown in Fig. 2.

Fig. 2

Type of graft (other: TFL and bone, bone and fat, and tensor fascia lata)

Distribution of the studied group according to the outcome of endoscopic endonasal repair is shown in Fig. 3, where the repair succeeded in 35 patients giving a success rate of 87.5%. Four of the remaining 5 patients needed reoperation, 3 of them by endoscopic approach and 1 by craniotomy with complete cure of the 4 patients, while 1 patient was non-operated lost from follow-up.

Fig. 3

Distribution of the studied group according to the outcome of endoscopic endonasal repair

Discussion

In our country, CSF rhinorrhea had been treated surgically by neurosurgeons using open approach (craniotomy) for many years with its high morbidities and mortalities.

In the last few years, a great move was done in our otolaryngology department at (blinded for review) for surgical specialties to treat such cases with CSF rhinorrhea by endonasal endoscopic approach. The present study tried to assess the use of nasal endoscopic technique in the management of cerebrospinal fluid rhinorrhea repair.

The mean age among the studied group was 30.7 years and this finding was close to that reported by Ta-Jen Lee et al. who found that the mean age was 36.8 years [15]. Arun Alexander et al. [16] reported that the age of the patients ranged from 6 to 61 years with a mean of 38.9 (± 11.57) years.

In the present study, females represented 29 (72.5%) of the studied group with a 2.63:1 female to male ratio. Yong-Gang Kong et al. [17] reported 17 males and 5 females among 22 cases. Muhammad Umar Farooq (2011) reported 13 males and 10 females among his 23 cases [18].

In our study, 10 patients had their CSF leak since birth, while the duration of CSF leak in the remaining 30 patients ranged between 2 and 22 months. Mohamad R. Chaaban et al. [19] reported that the estimated duration of symptoms at presentation averaged 14.3 months (range 1–120 months).

Symptomatic evaluation of patients in the present study, in addition to CSF leak, revealed that 40% of the patients had headache, 17.5% had repeated meningitis, 10% had nasal obstruction, when compared with the study done by Araujo Filho et al., who found that the major symptoms encountered by patients were clear rhinorrhea (98%), meningitis (9%), and seizures (7%) [20].

Regarding associated meningitis, it was found by Alexander, A. et al. that of the 34 patients with CSF rhinorrhea, 3 patients had a history of meningitis before surgery and was probably the reason for the diagnosis [16].

Our study reported that 50% of the patients had spontaneous CSF leak, 35% congenital, 15% traumatic, 5 of them surgical, and the remaining 1 patient with head trauma, which differs from the study conducted by Ta-Jen Lee et al. [15] who reported that 51% were traumatic, 15% spontaneous, and 33% iatrogenic. Araujo Filho et al. [20] reported that (32%) of the patients were traumatic and (39%) were spontaneous.

Our study reported that left cribriform plate was the most common site (37.5%), followed by right cribriform plate (27.5%). Left ethmoid sinus roof was the site of leak in 10%, while each of right ethmoid sinus roof and sphenoid sinus accounted for 12.55%. In the study of Ta-Jen Lee et al. [15], it was shown that 33.3% were cribriform plate, 40% from the ethmoids roof, 18% from the sphenoid, and 7.7% from the frontal sinus , while the study of Arun Alexander et al. [16] reported that fovea ethmoidalis was more common than cribriform plate with 55% and 29% respectively, while the frontal and sphenoid sinus was 5.9% for each.

Meningocele was present in 18(45%) of cases which agreed with Arun Alexander et al. who reported Meningoceles to be present in 14(41.1%) of the patients [16]. Yong-Gang Kong et al. [17] found two cases among 22 patients.

Skull base defect on CT was seen in 31/40 patients, while the study of Mohamad R. Chaaban (2014) indicated that 21/45 subjects had radiographic evidence of skull base defect [19].

In the majority of the patients (92.5%), the type of graft was TFL and fat while in the remaining 3 patients’ type of graft was TFL and bone, bone and fat, and tensor fascia lata. The decision of type of graft depends on size of defect, if the size was less than 1 cm tensor fascia lata and fat was used. When the size of defect is more than 1 cm, bone was added to the graft. We could not find other studies discussing the type of graft to compare their results with our results.

Success of surgery in the current study was indicated when the repair succeeded in 35 patients giving a success rate of 87.5%. Four of the remaining 5 patients needed reoperation while 1 patient was non-operated, and 3 of them were reoperated by endoscopic approach and 1 by craniotomy which was closed by surgery, and 1 patient was lost from follow-up.

Successful endoscopic repairs were accomplished in 90% of patients during the first attempt as reported by Hegazy et al. [14]. Kirtane et al. [21] had success rate of 96.63%. While many other studies reported more than 80% success rates [20, 22,23,24,25].

The results of this study should be evaluated in light of its strengths and limitations. Being among few hospitals which carry out this new surgical technique, describing this procedure is the main strength of our study. One of the limitations of the study was type of the research question which is descriptive in nature. This is due to the fact that this technique is still new and we do not have another group of patients to carry out a comparative study. Finally, the results of this paper might not be generalizable since the patients were selected from one hospital.

Conclusion

It can be concluded that wide range of age groups from 2 to 62 years presented as CSF rhinorrhea with female predominance, and there was high success rate of endoscopic CSF rhinorrhea repair with low morbidity.