Skip to main content

Table 3 Results of the included studies

From: Role and efficacy of music therapy in learning disability: a systematic review

 

1. Riberio and Santos, 2017 [12]

2. Habib et al., 2016 [11]

3. Flaugnacco et al., 2015 [13]

4. Skeja, 2014 [14]

5. Cogo-Moreira et al., 2013 [15]

6. Register et al., 2007 [16]

7. Overy, 2003 [17]

Reading

 

-Study2:

Significant improvement

-Music group:

Greater improvement in pseudowords reading

 

-By ITT:

Non-significant in non-word accuracy, marginally significant in word accuracy, no observed improvement in text accuracy

-By CACE:

Significant in word accuracy and text accuracy

-Reading disability class:

Significant in WD, WK, and RC

-Control class:

Significant in WD and WK, made gains not significantly in RC

-Treatment class:

As in control class

-Study1:

Non-significant in no risk group and mild risk group and strong risk group

Phonological awareness

 

-Study (1):

Normalization in identification and discrimination, strong improvement in syllabic duration

-Study (2):

Higher than before in identification and discrimination, significant improvement in phonological tasks

-Music group:

Better performance in phonemic blending task

 

-By ITT:

No observed improvement

-By CACE:

Significant

 

-Study (1):

Significant improvement in all 3 groups

-Study (2):

Significant positive effect

Spelling

      

-Study (1):

Non-significant in no risk group, significant in mild risk group, and strong risk group

-Study (2):

Significant

Writing

 

-Study (2):

Significant improvement in letter sequence comparison, no change in contour discrimination

     

Arithmetic

-Both EA and LA: significant improvement in CB, DN, MC, RN, CE, and PS

-Only LA:

increased scores in PN

-Only EA: Increased scores in CD and WC

   

-By ITT and CACE:

Significant

  

Cognitive abilities

  

-Control (painting) group:

Greater improvement in visuo-spatial reasoning

Significant difference between experimental group and control group

   

Auditory attention

 

-Study (2):

Significant improvement

-Music group:

Larger effect

    

Rapid auditory processing

      

-Study (2):

Significant

Working memory

  

-Music group:

Greater improvement

    
  1. EA expected achievement, LA low achievement, CD counting dots, CB counting backwards, DN dictation of numbers, MC mental calculation, RN reading numbers, PN positioning numbers, OC oral comparison, CE contextual estimation, PS problem solving, Wc written comparison.